Sustainable Health & Development - Keynote |
|
Panel 1: The Components of Global Health Security, MNCH, and Infectious Disease Agendas, is Integration Possible? |
|
Panel 2: Changing the Infrastructure of Global Health, Exploring South-South and Triangular Cooperation for Sustainable Health and Development |
|
Panel 3: 15 Years of Collaborations: Champions and Partnerships |
|
Panel 4: Decreasing Complexity to Encouraging Private Sector Investment in Health |
|
Panel 5: Private Sector Mobilization |
|
In 2014 GHD brought together key stakeholders for its Post-2015 Infrastructure for Development Conference to highlight the future of global health architecture, identify forthcoming challenges, and promote best practices among a wide variety of sectors and communities. With the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) now before us, GHD aims to reunite key stakeholders in continued discussion of financing mechanisms, multilateral cooperation, technological advances, past successes, and cross-sectoral coordination. By convening top experts and leaders for discussion on these five topics, the conference aims to catalyze change at the political, policy, and technical/implementation levels. GHD will closely facilitate each of the five discussions so as to build on the momentum and outcomes of the previous session and help move the conversation forward towards action.
|
------------------------------------- AGENDA -------------------------------------- Breakfast 8:00 am Keynote Speaker Michel Sidibé Executive Director of UNAIDS 8:30am - 9:55am The Components of Global Health Security MNCH and UHC is Integration Possible? 10:15am - 11:30am Exploring South-South and Triangular Cooperation for Sustainable Health and Development Sharing Successful Practices, Gaps, and Opportunities LUNCHEON CELEBRATION 12:05 pm - 1:00 pm 15 Years of Collaborations: Champions and Partnerships Recognizing the Leaders and Programs which have Generated Change During the Millennium Development Goals 1:00 pm - 1:50 pm Decreasing Complexity to Encourage Private Sector Investments in Health A Discussion with Donor and Emerging Market Governments and CEOs from the private sector - working in partnership for better health outcomes. 1:50 pm - 3:00 pm Private Sector Mobilization Building in-country and regional capacity: the Global Financing Facility (GFF) A Discussion with GFF principals and private sector 3:15 pm - 4:30 pm Cocktail Hour & Closing Remarks
|
Keynote Address | By Michel Sidibé, Executive Director of UNAIDS, Under-Secretary-General of the UN |
During his keynote address at the Sustainable Health and Development event, UNAIDS Executive Director and Under-Secretary-General of the United Nations, Michel Sidibé reflected on the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) achievements around HIV/AIDS, and how lessons learned from this experience could shape the implementation of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). He stressed the need to evolve our thinking around global health partnerships post-2015, especially in terms of encouraging public private partnerships (PPPs) that are result-focused, people-centric as far as deliverables and participation, and that leverage existing resources in low and middle-income countries. He attributed the success of the MDG #6 (combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases) to global solidarity, the successful mobilization of resources, and the shift from disease focused approaches to a strategy that linked HIV/AIDS to other issues including maternal, newborn and child health (MNCH), tuberculosis, and human rights. In this effort to deal with health in general, governments engaged civil society groups and the private sector in ways that introduced new debates on shared responsibility, shared investments in research and development, and drug price negotiations. According to Mr. Sidibé, these dynamics have changed the paradigm of treating people through the use of science as a force of activism, and more African governments increasing their health budgets, establishing antidiscrimination programs, and mobilizing more resources to support women and adolescent girls. Additionally, there is a growing realization that health security is not possible without individual risk management, and that in order to address issues such as climate change and new energy, we must first deal with the health of the people. Mr. Sidibé stated that setting ambitious goals inspires transformation, and stressed the importance of political will in successfully transitioning from disease-specific approaches to contemplating the overall health of a population. He encourages the community to view health as not a cost, but an investment in the population, and calls for a data revolution to facilitate decision making at the country level and strengthen the management of emerging epidemics. |
Panel 1: The Components of Global Health Security, MNCH, and Infectious Disease Agendas, is Integration Possible? |
Transitioning from Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) to Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), panelists shared best practices they believe will enable governments, multilateral organizations, and the private sector to work in a more integrated manner to solve global health issues. The panel addressed challenges in meeting broad and ambitious goals such as Sustainable Development Goal # 3: “to ensure healthy lives and promote wellbeing for all at all ages”. Other issues discussed included the failure to meet MDGs # 4 and 5, which deal with maternal, newborn and child health, the need to empower leadership at the community and country levels, and the roles of the private sector and government in initiatives such as the global health security agenda (GHSA).
Speakers
Although maternal, newborn and child health has improved greatly over the past decade, MDGs # 4 and 5, which target infant and maternal mortality, are lagging behind. In response to this, governments have partnered with NGOs, civil society, and private sector in movements such as Every Woman, Every Child, to address major health challenges facing women and children. This movement has since grown to include Every Adolescent, Everywhere, in an effort to address growing needs in humanitarian settings [Temmerman]. The panel agreed that learning from these successful partnerships was critical to the success of SGDs, and welcomed WHO’s Dr. Marleen Temmerman’s announcement of the launch of a special supplement in the BMJ (British Medical Journal) focusing on a variety of topics including women, children and adolescent issues in humanitarian settings, financing of global initiatives, impact of social determinants and human rights. In addition to cross-sectoral partnerships, France believes the successful implementation of the SDGs will require creative approaches and innovation means to improve financing mechanism instruments, building a robust health workforce, and alleviating health security issues. There was consensus that health ministries should work closely with other ministries such as education, finance and diplomacy to maintain political attention on health. In addition to mobilizing through G7, France has joined the Global Health and Foreign Policy initiative along with Senegal, Norway, Brazil, Indonesia and South Africa to bring public health issues at the top of the global political agenda [Bontems]. There was a concern that having broad goals that were not addressing specific issues could result in complacency. WHO’s plan to eliminate tuberculosis by 2035 for instance is not on track; UK Parliament’s Mr. Nick Herbert added that at the current rate, it would take approximate 2 centuries to eliminate TB. Some reasons for the lag in the fight against TB are shortage in finances, old fashioned tools, and inadequate health systems [Herbert]. Panelists agreed that health should be seen as an investment instead of an expenditure, especially because of its positive effects on nations’ economic growth. There is a push for European countries to adopt models that would use taxes on industries such as oil, to benefit population health [Bontems]. Panelists shared excitement over the increased engagement of the private sector in global health, but highlighted the need to invest in stronger leadership nationally as to empower governments to more effectively identify needs and coordinate collaborative responses [Temmerman]. |
Panel 2 | Exploring South-South and Triangular Cooperation for Sustainable Health and Development |
< |
Participants discussed how South-South and triangular partnerships could apply lessons learned over the years to disseminate and scale up lasting and impacting collaborations around various global health issues. Speakers identified specific barriers to creating partnerships between country governments, multilateral organizations, and the private sector to tackle ambitious global health and development goals. Panelists drew from their own experiences to identify key factors for success—such as political will, communication, and supporting infrastructure—and discussed the future of South-South and triangular partnerships in the post-2015 development context.
Speakers
The vast majority of people living with HIV are living in the global South, and the burden of non-communicable disease is rising disproportionally among low-to-middle-income countries. No one organization or country is capable of addressing these issues, thus the need for greater harmonization of efforts between governments, private sector, academia, civil society and the general public. The SDGs’ focus on the welfare of the people and the planet highlights the importance of a more holistic approach to health, but requires UN agencies and the global health community to respond in concrete ways scale up viable collaborations and share best practices that are adaptable. Such a successful collaboration under the UN Office of South-South cooperation was the partnership of the Uganda government with Cipla, an Indian pharmaceutical company, and Quality Chemicals Limited (QCL), a Ugandan pharmaceutical company. This partnership widened Cipla’s reach and network, established a pharmaceutical manufacturing plant in Kampala, and produced low cost medication while increasing access to HIV/AIDS treatment [Liu]. Another success story is the the South-South Global Health Exchange (SS-GHX), a joint initiative of the Special Unit for South-South Cooperation at the United Nations Development Programme, with WHO’s regional office of the Americans, and the Pan American health Organization (PAHO) to enhances cooperation, knowledge sharing and exchange among developing and developed countries on successful practices for health and development [Liu]. Panelist agreed that it was critical to have absolute numbers associated with the SDGs that would allow global health actors to set series of short term goals to build momentum toward larger concrete goals such as UN’s goal to avert 21 million AIDS-related deaths and 28 million new infections by 2030. Key issues to consider when innovating global health outreach infrastructure are affordability of commodity by asking questions and addressing trade restrictions that may impact pricing, achieving a common regulatory market system to facilitate the registration of commodities in multiple countries at once, and solving availability issues through tracking systems and transnational mechanisms that could immediately mitigate stock-outs [UNAIDS representative]. In addition to affordability, technologies and other commodities also need to be adapted to the local circumstances as some equipment perform differently depending on temperature or are negatively affected by vibrations from transportation. Siemens Healthcare’s success in combining mobile medical technology and telemedicine has enabled governments in countries like Peru to invest in high technology in cities, and ensure that surrounding regions and countryside inhabitants benefit from these investments through hub-and-spoke models [Frank]. An emphasis should be placed on listening to each partner country represented so that targeted interventions appropriate for each country are implemented, on respecting the differences of each of these countries as not all solutions are feasible or appropriate in each Southern country, and on building trust between countries, the private sector, and multilateral organizations so that effective partnerships can be formed for the promotion of health for all [Faria]. Panelists concluded that while it is important to target specific illnesses when implementing broad, ambitious goals, a holistic approach is needed in healthcare. Better healthcare begins with availability of basic resources such as clean water and better sanitation. Science, technology and innovations were seen as key drivers for bringing desired changes in meeting those goals. These drivers however can only accomplish so much when there are many more patients than doctors able to treat them in most low and middle income countries. |
Panel 3: 15 Years of Collaborations: Champions and Partnerships |
< |
Recognizing the Leaders and Programs which have Generated Change during the Millennium Development Goals This celebratory lunch highlighted champions, as well as organization and partnership leaders, and provided a platform for them to share best practices and reflect upon the qualities that made the MDGs so successful, as well as lessons learned which should be heeded going forward. The implementation of the MDGs in 2000 greatly shaped the landscape of global health. Since their inception and implementation, the global health community has made great progress. Over the past fifteen years, new partnerships, such as GAVI, the Global Fund, and UNITAID were created to meet our collective goals, and the global health and development community saw the emergence of many great global health leaders. Honored Guests
Political will and engagement of the people affected is crucial to the success of any movement. Global solidarity is a primary driver for change, which only occurs through a people centric approach that engages the private sector, and integrates science and technology. MDG #6, to combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases, was achieved 9 months before timeframe, and is the first UN goal to be achieved ahead of time [Sidibé]. Utilizing Canada’s Aid Effectiveness Agenda, donors coordinated with their country leadership, and this opportunity for large scale program under ministries of health and education was successful in concentrating efforts and enhancing capacity rather than diffusing it through competing projects [Paradis]. New approaches such as GAVI’s facilitated the scaling up of successful pilots and led to focused results. Partnerships such as the Global Fund showcased strengths of various partners; innovation and risk tolerance of private sector, track record and experience of bilateral donors, resources of multilateral development banks, and leadership and contextual knowledge of country partners [Paradis]. Lessons learned include the need for broader partnerships, an information culture of good data, regular reporting and transparency, and innovation in all aspects of global health architecture, from technology to communication of cost-effective tools. Next Steps It is important to think about the next five years as an opportunity to break the backbone of the HIV/AIDS epidemic and prevent its resurface. Global health security will never happen without individual health risk management [Sidibé]. In order to achieve a new paradigm in global health, every organization needs to engage the private sector, civil society, and government agencies. We must continue to reexamine and reinvent our approaches to work more strategically with actors from all sectors of society and develop and finance interventions that ensure healthier lives for all [Paradis]. |
Panel 4: Decreasing Complexity to Encouraging Private Sector Investment in Health |
Overview Speakers
Outcomes The global health community has adopted a more integrative perspective in its work with the private sector, multilateral organizations and governments, the focus is now to continue this work and engage partners across sectors to take innovations to scale. The SDGs bring attention to a gap in funding for critical health, education, food security and climate adaptation issues across the world [Paradis]. Power of blended finance is being harnessed to increase investment in emerging markets health issues such as maternal newborn and child health (MNCH). Canada supports the Global Financing Facility as a model for sustainable financing and sees it as an opportunity for private sector to co-invest in the health of populations in needs. Canada is also working with the Word Economic Forum (WEF) and other partners on the redesigning of development finance initiative effectively identify and promote innovative solutions to finance the world’s development needs. One such collaboration is in the development of Convergence, the first platform available for sharing knowledge and forging blended finance partnerships [Paradis]. In addition to holding all partners involved to the same degree of transparency and accountability, governments, private sector and civil society need to speak the same language to decrease complexity in global health investment. It is only in the combination of skills and core competencies of various sectors that global challengeds can be solved, therefore in addition in to blended finance, we need blended responsibility [Cohen]. While agreeing with this unified approach, Terri Bresenham of GE Healthcare stressed the need to co-create solutions to these challenges with the people affected and those expected to sustain those initiatives in the communities. This inclusion will keep us from replicating western models in developing countries, and instead build models that are tailored to their economy and are culturally sensitive [Bresenham]. BD has demonstrated how impactful and profitable partnerships can be by working with WHO and Grand Challenges Canada to bring the Odon device to scale. This device was created by an Argentinian mechanic and has revolutionized maternal newborn and child health by addressing obstructed and prolonged second stage labor, the cause of up to 25 percent of maternal and newborn mortality [Cohen]. In partnership with Canada and Global Health Investment Fund, BD is launching two new diagnostic tests for preeclampsia and gestational diabetes, two leading causes of maternal mortality. Initial innovation is only a part of the battle, the heavy lifting is getting products to scale, and large companies can tap on existing competencies for that. GE has been working with domestic and multinational partners and agencies such as WHO and IFC to raise awareness of affordable interventions, promote localization of engineering, mechanism and ownership of interventions, innovate the business model to emphasize a win-win approach, and invest in skills development and education. Through its partnership with the Kenyan government, GE not only brought state of the art diagnostics to 98 hospitals across the country, but was also critical in building capacity and training leadership and management to strengthen Kenya’s healthcare system. GE training of workers, and introduction of compact ultrasound 3D imaging technologies in hard to reach areas proved how impactful it is to not only design tools for the intended environment but to also involve the citizens in those areas [Bresenham]. Next Steps The SDGs have identified the needs, it’s now time to find ways to finance them. Canada intends to establish a development finance initiative to provide financing to companies operating in low and middle income countries with activities complimenting Canada’s international assistance priorities. In order to encourage private sector investment in health, new approaches need to be data driven, which enables them to achieve tangible results. Transparency and accountability need to be maintained for all partners to address risks and uncertainties plaguing investments in emerging markets. There is a need for the new business model in global health to include both blended finance and responsibility, but also have a micro economic reward for all involved. We need to continue to support platforms that allow actors to know what is happening in the global health community and avoid duplication of efforts. |
Panel 5: Global Financing Facility (GFF) |
Building In-Country and Regional Capacity – the Global Financing Facility (GFF) While the Global Financing Faciliy (GFF), launched in July 2015, has already aligned billions dollars to country-led plans for women’s, children’s and adolescents’ health in the four GFF front-runner countries of the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Ethiopia, Kenya and Tanzania more remains to be done to end maternal and child mortality by 2030. With the private sector now making up the bulk of foreign direct investment, the International Development Association (IDA) needs to work in partnership with the private sector to close the funding and expertise gaps that impede many emerging markets from growing to their full potential. This forum focused on promising financing models, and interventions that are in the process of scaling up through private sector engagement. Additionally, the panelists brainstormed on GFF’s work in partnering with the private sector, including how new partners can get involved, and how the GFF sees the role of private sector going forward. Speakers
The UN recognized the great opportunity GFF has as the world first consolidated financing instrument for maternal, newborn and child health and got involved right away. Its housing in the Word Bank Group facilitates the de-risking of investments, and allow poor countries without previous access to World Bank funds to benefit from this model. The core of the GFF is the engagement of the private sector and its diverse entities. Private sector is not only useful for financial resource, but for its expertise and technology innovations [Basu]. Norway has been a great leader for maternal, newborn and child health, and was one of the first country to mobilize private sector through the Every Women Every Child initiative. Norway supports GFF because it recognizes that as we move into the post 2015 era, ODA will continue to decrease and needs to be linked to both domestic financing and private sector through the World Bank, which already engages the private sector. GFF builds on the Health Results Innovation Trust Fund, created in 2007 and supported by the governments of Norway and UK [Godal]. The Trust Fund is in fact a part of GFF, which brings together multiple partners to align behind country plans and achieve results on the ground. The success of GFF rests on its three pillars; smart financing through high impact cost effective interventions at the country level, scaling up using private sector and already available domestic resources, and sustainability by helping countries grow their domestic resources to help their transition from low to middle income countries without losing support. GFF investment cases recognize the issue of bottlenecks in the health system in terms of human resources and supply chain [World Bank representative]. The private sector can be seen as early stage investors instead of philanthropists, and leads innovation by providing new ways of doing things, from financing to scaling up. GE Foundation built a cost effective scalable oxygen generators distribution system that could be built at the district level and supply regional hospitals with canisters of oxygen at a very reasonable price. This was a creative investments with little initial risks that’s now in need for sustainable capital to scale it. Private sector has skillsets in business, manufacturing education and training that will be of great value to the global health environment. There was a call for more creative and tactful partnerships. David Barash of GE Healthcare proposed adding another “P” to PPP, making it Public-Private-Private partnerships, stressing the need for greater collaboration between private sector members. As each them bring different skillsets to the table, encouraging members of private sector to work with each other with the support of GFF would lead to greater impact and efficiency [Barash] GFF will need the private sector’s help in reaching out to new players in the field [Pablos-Méndez]. The World Bank has set up an investors group to help incentivize private sector and prioritize needs in a very dynamic environment. The prioritization and appropriation of GFF funds is very country specific [World Bank representative]. Norway sees health and education as the most important investments to build country resilience and prevent future crises [Godal]. GE Healthcare pointed out the need to have infrastructure in place to process geopolitical crises in a way that easily engages public and private sectors. Agreeing with Norway’s view on health and education as key to preventing future outbreak, David Barash attributed the success to GE’s partnership with Last Mile Health in Liberia to their strong commitment to health worker programs as a tool to strengthen health systems and prevent outbreaks [Barash]. Investments being made have to involve health systems; human and infrastructure resources need to be considered when investing in specific services [Pablos-Méndez]. |
Please join us for the launch of the National Action Plan for Combating MDR-TB hosted by the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), in collaboration with the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, and the National Security Council. |
Video available Thursday, January 7th USAID |
Join us for a live webcast of |
Featuring Dr. Jim Yong Kim Dr. Paul Farmer Dr. Aaron Motsoaledi
Moderated by: Kojo Nnamdi
Tuberculosis is the world's leading infectious killer, causing more than 4,000 deaths every day. As the lead U.S. Government agency for international TB care efforts, USAID is committed to reach every person with TB, cure those in need of treatment, and prevent new TB infections, as outlined in the U.S. Government Global TB Strategy and the recently released White House National Action Plan for Combating Multidrug-Resistant Tuberculosis. |